The Cincinnati Bengals remain in contention for the AFC playoffs as the 2024 NFL regular season approaches its final weekend—a notable achievement given their sluggish start to the year. However, failing to secure a postseason spot (to borrow Cody Rhodes’ phrase, “finish the story”) would render the season a significant disappointment.
Here, we’ll examine three critical questions the Bengals face ahead of their must-win Week 18 matchup against the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Will Chase Brown be able to play in Week 18?
Late in the fourth quarter of the game against Denver, running back Chase Brown suffered what appeared to be an ankle injury. Following an MRI, it was confirmed to be a high ankle sprain. According to Jordan Schultz of Fox Sports, Brown’s availability for the must-win game against Pittsburgh will depend on his recovery throughout the week. Schultz also noted that Brown is “determined” to suit up for the pivotal matchup.
Beyond Brown, the Bengals’ backfield depth is thin. The only other experienced back on the active roster is Khalil Herbert, who was acquired via trade before the deadline and has logged just eight carries for 45 yards in a Bengals uniform. Behind him is Trayveon Williams, who has yet to record a carry this season. Meanwhile, Zack Moss, signed in free agency, remains on injured reserve with a neck injury. Essentially, the Bengals are banking on Brown being ready to play. Keep an eye on updates regarding his status as the week progresses.
Does Cincinnati have a kicking problem?
Evan McPherson has been sidelined for the past four games due to a groin injury, and his availability for Week 18 remains uncertain. Before the injury, McPherson faced notable struggles, converting just 72.7% of his field goal attempts (16 of 22). This marks a career-low for him and is among the lowest in the league this season. Prior to 2024, McPherson had never posted a conversion rate below 82% in any season. The Bengals will be closely monitoring his progress as they approach their critical must-win game.
Cade York has been stepping in for Evan McPherson, but his performance has raised concerns. In Week 17 against Denver, York missed a potential game-winning 33-yard field goal, hitting the upright instead. It was a prime opportunity for York to shine, but he couldn’t deliver. This miss has understandably led to questions about how much trust the coaching staff can place in him heading into the must-win game against Pittsburgh. A lack of confidence in York could significantly influence the team’s offensive strategy, potentially prompting more aggressive decisions to avoid relying on field goals.
Will the Bengals get the help they need from other teams?
The Bengals’ playoff hopes aren’t entirely in their hands—they’ll need some help to secure a postseason berth. Specifically, Cincinnati needs the New York Jets to defeat the Miami Dolphins and the Kansas City Chiefs to beat the Denver Broncos. While both outcomes are possible, neither is a given. Still, crazier scenarios have played out in the NFL.
Bengals fans will have clarity by Saturday night, as the Jets-Dolphins and Chiefs-Broncos games will determine if Sunday’s action matters. If Cincinnati can defeat the Steelers, their playoff hopes hinge on those results. However, a loss to Pittsburgh would render the Sunday slate irrelevant, signaling an early start to the offseason for the Bengals.