The St. Louis Cardinals likely hoped that the pairing of him and star would lead them to multiple championships. However, the team has faced challenges, with ups and downs over recent years, and he is now emerging as a potential trade candidate.
During his four-year tenure with the Cardinals, Arenado was selected to three All-Star teams, but he’s only had one season that truly reflected his full offensive potential. In 2022, he delivered a standout performance, slashing .293/.358/.533/.891 and placing third in MVP voting. In his other seasons, however, his highest OPS was .807 in 2021.
In 2024, he struggled, recording his lowest numbers in St. Louis with a .272/.325/.394/.719 line, hitting just 16 home runs and 23 doubles. At 33, questions arise about whether this is a sign of decline or if he still has star potential that might flourish with a change of scenery. Many teams believe in his high ceiling, making him an intriguing trade option.
his remains under contract through 2027, with a substantial salary. The Cardinals may need to cover part of his contract to facilitate a trade. Here are five ideal trade destinations for Arenado:
New York Yankees
The Yankees narrowly missed a World Series title in 2024, losing to the Dodgers. Their priority is to re-sign Juan Soto and possibly add Pete Alonso. Arenado could be a valuable addition, especially if Gleyber Torres, a free agent, doesn’t return. Though the Yankees might hesitate to add another aging star with a large contract, Arenado’s potential could make it worthwhile.
Detroit Tigers
With a return to the postseason in 2024, the Tigers are on the rise. Arenado would be a valuable veteran addition, bringing leadership to Detroit’s young roster. Given the Tigers’ stockpile of prospects, they could make a tempting offer for Arenado, who might appreciate joining an up-and-coming team.
Los Angeles Dodgers
As reigning World Series champions, the Dodgers are often linked to top players. Max Muncy may not be a long-term solution at third base, and with a deep pool of prospects, the Dodgers could engage in trade talks for Arenado.
Kansas City Royals
Like the Tigers, the Royals made strides in 2024. Adding Arenado would bolster their infield alongside Bobby Witt Jr. and provide leadership to a young roster. Kansas City’s potential could attract Arenado, and the proximity to St. Louis might ease his transition.
Houston Astros
If the Astros don’t re-sign Alex Bregman, Arenado could be a strong replacement. Houston is consistently competitive, and Arenado’s desire to win could align well with the Astros’ goals. Although the Astros didn’t meet expectations in 2024, they remain a contender, making a trade to Houston appealing for Arenado.
Will Arenado be traded?
While the Cardinals aren’t obligated to trade Arenado, they may consider it to revitalize their roster. If the Cardinals cover part of his contract, a trade could happen soon, either this offseason or before the 2025 trade deadline.
